Hi Charles! Thanks for more info and names on the Rentie Family Clan. Sho' glad to see Donald has joined in on this Rentie Family Puzzle Name Game as well.
From my Great Uncle Joseph Rentie's (His Father was Benjamin Franklin Rentie) Family Writings, he shows a Pickett Rentie II as one of the Sons of Island Rentie. This could be the very Theodore Pickett Rentie you've mentioned who married Eleanor Peaches Alwell. Thus Theodore Pickett Rentie II's Son William Rentie definitely is not the Rentiesville co-Founder William "Bill" Rentie because this kid is only 9 years old (if he was born in 1901 as you say) when the much older William Rentie is murdered in 1910 as the Rentiesville Town Sheriff. I got more name items to add in my next reply to Donald.
Also my hyperlink to the incredible passage stories on Fannie Bumpus Rentie was composed gathered and uploaded by our Moderator Angela herself!
Let's Keep The Faith!