You wrote (in part):

"Now to go back and try discover John Baskerville's parents - his wife Amanda is also a Baskerville, daughter of Hawkins Baskerville.
This family makes me nuts - there are several Baskerville-Baskerville marriages and FTM doesn't want me to enter the data

Denise"

Have you tried putting the maiden names of BASKERVILLE in the box for the given names? For example, if Mary Ann Baskerville married John Henry Baskerville, put her entire name, including Baskerville in the box for the given name. Leave the surname box blank. Maybe you can "fool" FTM's database into accepting it.

Georgia Walker-Adams