Mariah was really Maria Frances Barber, born to Margaret and Elias in 1833 and died 1864 at age 31.
Sara Ann was her elder sister by Elias's first wife, Jane Shumate, she married Andrew Jackson Sewell, she died 1853 at age 28, had one child who is on the 1860 census at 8 years of age.
Arthur William Barber, born 1829 to first wife, married Caroline Smith and do not know anything else about him.
Elizabeth George married William Starkey, was Margaret and Elias second child, she died 35 years old. All her children went by the Starkey name.
Thomas Edward, was born 1837 and died 1839, 2 years of age.
Margaret Lettica Barber, died at 49 in 1888, buried beside her parents.
Susan Jane Barber, died 1867 at age 25 no marriage as far as we know.
John Snead Barber died in a Union prison 1863 after having been captured near Bellfonte while home on leave, he died at 18 in 1963.
Josephine Barber, married Eustis and moved to Texas.
Bernard Elias moved to Texas in the 1860's, never came back, had lots of children, none by those names.
Virginia (Jennie) married Samuel Wyatt Kennemer, died at 44, no children.
Judson Barber, married Nannie C. Morton and died 1931, he had three children, Katie Bell who married a Holder, Lina Mae who married a Phillips and Judson Emmett who married Annie Maude Gentry.
I have searched everything I have, cannot find anything.
Could you please send me a copy of 1880 census, Elias would have been about 82 at that time, he died in 1884.