Thanks again, Tony. I think I know the William Broxie that you found, the one that shows Paul & Laura as his parents. I'm looking for the William whose mother's name was Nellie Estella Graham, as stated on William's social security application. No, I don't have any info on Essie, not a clue. Thank you for checking the 1920 census again. Everytime I tried to decipher it, I could not figure whether or not it stated widow, or not. It never occurred to me to try for a marriage certificate. I guess I just figured that would be almost impossible to obtain with the minimal info that I have. You have been a big help. Thank You. Yvonne