Any clues here?
RICKMAN ABNER 64 M TN OH HIGHLAND PENN 1880
RICKMAN ABNER 43 M TN OH ROSS BAINBRIDGE; PAXTON 1880
RICKMAN ABNER 13 M OH OH ROSS BAINBRIDGE; PAXTON

Not the same Abner. Most likely some relation though. This is why I was careful in my response to say that I don't believe this Abner RICKMAN (husband of Telitha) ever made it to Ohio.