Steven,

I'm confused about what you are seeking. Conflicting information is the norm in genealogy research. You gather as much credible evidence as you can find. What evidence is providing this conflicting information ? Are you relying on Isaac's census records for this information ? I wouldn't consider Isaac's census data to be strong evidence. I looked at Henry's 1850, 1860 and 1870 census records and they are conflicting. Two census records indicate VA and one list TN. You need to expound a little more. I assume you've reviewed Paul's website and did not find your answer there. If you shared more of your evidence possibly someone could assist.

Ron